Electing S corporation status can offer valuable tax benefits. But the election is only the beginning. How you pay yourself, take money out, fund the business and change ownership can all affect your tax results.

Whether your company elected S status when it started or converted from a C corporation, these are the issues to understand—and the conversations to have with your tax advisor before decisions are made.

1.  The company profit or loss flows to the Shareholder’s personal tax returns

An S corporation generally passes its taxable income through to its owners, who report their shares on their personal returns. The business issues each owner a Schedule K-1 showing that share. Leaving cash in the company does not, by itself, defer the owner’s tax.

For example, if you own 100% of the company and it has $200,000 of taxable profit after wages and other deductible expenses, you generally report that $200,000 even if the company distributes only $60,000. Your wages are reported separately on Form W-2.

Build distributions for income tax associated with the S-Corporation’s profit into the company’s cash-flow planning. With multiple owners, agree in advance on an approach to issuing distributions to cover the taxes. Your advisor can help coordinate estimated payments and wage withholding.

2.  Working owners need reasonable compensation

If you perform services for the business, payments to you must be treated as wages to the extent they represent reasonable compensation before being treated as nonwage distributions. Wages carry payroll tax and reporting obligations. Calling all withdrawals “distributions” does not avoid those rules.

There is no universal salary percentage or IRS-approved “60/40 rule.” Appropriate pay depends on your duties, time, experience and comparable compensation. Document the reasoning and revisit it as the business changes.

3.  Distributions are not the same as wages

A distribution is generally an owner’s withdrawal of equity, not a deductible business expense. Nondividend cash distributions generally avoid additional tax only to the extent of your stock basis; an excess generally creates capital gain. Companies with prior C corporation earnings can have different results.

4.  Track your investment and loans

“Basis” is your tax investment in the business. It changes with contributions, income, losses and distributions. Your stock basis is not simply the cash balance or retained earnings shown in the books. Shareholders are responsible for tracking basis, often using Form 7203.

Document money you put into the company as either capital or a genuine loan. A bank loan to the corporation, even one you guarantee, generally does not create shareholder debt basis. Repayment of a shareholder loan can become taxable if prior losses reduced its tax basis.

5.  Keep business spending and personal spending separate

Use separate business bank accounts and cards, and reconcile the books regularly. Clearly identify payroll, distributions, contributions and loans. Paying a personal bill through the company does not turn it into a business deduction.

For business expenses you pay personally, consider an accountable reimbursement plan. Proper reimbursements require a business connection, timely documentation and return of excess advances. Keep receipts and mileage records; ask how qualifying home-office expenses should be handled.

6.  Coordinate benefits and retirement with payroll

Health insurance for an employee who owns more than 2% of the company requires special handling. Generally, the company must pay or reimburse the premiums and include them in the owner’s W-2 Box 1 for the owner to claim the related self-employed health insurance deduction, if eligible. Family ownership rules can also apply. Other fringe benefits may receive different treatment than they do for regular employees.

Retirement contributions for an owner-employee generally depend on eligible W-2 compensation, not shareholder distributions. Coordinate salary, retirement goals and employee coverage requirements before year-end.

7.  Review the qualified business income deduction

Eligible owners may receive a federal deduction of up to 20% of qualified business income. It is not automatic: taxable income, business type, wages and qualifying property can affect the result. Your employee wages are not qualified business income. Review the deduction alongside compensation and retirement planning.

8.  Protect the election when ownership changes

S corporations have limits on who may own shares, generally cannot exceed 100 shareholders and may have only one class of stock for tax purposes. A transfer to an ineligible owner can terminate S status. Trusts require particular care, including possible elections and deadlines.

Have your advisors review gifts, sales, new investors, estate planning and equity compensation before shares change hands. Governing documents must preserve identical rights to distributions and liquidation proceeds, although voting rights can differ. Different salaries for different work are permissible; preferential ownership economics require careful review.

Income generally follows ownership on a per-share, per-day basis. A midyear transfer may call for a permitted election to close the books for tax allocation purposes. Bring your tax advisor into the transaction before signing.

9.  Plan for filings and state taxes

The company generally files Form 1120-S and provides K-1s annually. For a calendar-year company, the usual federal deadline is March 15, adjusted for weekends and holidays. An extension to file does not extend payment deadlines. Payroll and information returns have separate due date schedules, and late S corporation returns can trigger penalties even without federal income tax due.

State rules may differ. For example, California generally taxes S corporation income at 1.5%, with an $800 minimum franchise tax subject to exceptions. Other states may impose their own entity taxes, elections or owner withholding requirements.

Tell your advisor when you hire remotely, expand into another state or change where owners live. Also ask whether an elective state pass-through entity tax is beneficial and what payment deadlines apply.

10.  Converting from a C corporation needs extra planning

An S election does not erase the company’s C corporation tax history. Before converting—or selling assets after a conversion—review these additional issues:

  • Built-in gains: Selling appreciated assets during the generally five-year federal recognition period can create corporate-level tax in addition to the shareholder tax consequences. Certain income attributable to the C corporation period, such as collections of receivables for a cash-method business, can also be affected. Document asset values and tax bases at conversion.
  • Prior earnings: Accumulated C corporation earnings and profits can cause some distributions to be taxable dividends.
  • Other carryovers: C corporation losses generally do not become deductions on owners’ returns. Review any remaining tax attributes, inventory accounting and conversion-related taxes with your advisor.

Make tax planning part of running the business

Schedule a planning conversation before year-end and before major transactions. Bring updated financials, expected profits, owner withdrawals, payroll information and planned ownership or operating changes. Regular communication helps connect the company’s decisions with your personal tax position and gives you time to act.

 

For More Reading:

 

Aura Advisors is a boutique tax consulting and compliance firm working with start-ups, emerging growth companies, and affluent individuals. Making it safer for good people and good companies to continue to do good things.